A few years ago, insurance barely came up in a real estate transaction. Now it’s often one of the first questions a buyer asks, and one of the first things a seller should check before putting a sign in the yard. California’s home insurance market has been through a rough stretch, and while there are signs it’s stabilizing, it still shapes how smart buyers and sellers plan their moves here in Ventura County.
What’s Been Happening Statewide
Over the past several years, a number of private insurers pulled back on writing new homeowners policies in parts of California, particularly in and near higher wildfire-risk areas. That pushed more properties onto the California FAIR Plan, the state’s insurer of last resort, which was never designed to carry the volume it ended up carrying.
The state has been working to turn that around. Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara’s Sustainable Insurance Strategy is aimed at bringing private insurers back into higher-risk markets, in exchange for letting them use updated, forward-looking wildfire catastrophe models when they set rates. According to the California Department of Insurance, growth in FAIR Plan enrollment has slowed noticeably this year compared to the pace of the last few, which regulators are pointing to as an early sign the broader market is leveling out. It’s progress, but it’s not the same as a return to how things worked a decade ago, and it’s still an evolving situation.
Why It Matters Here in Ventura County
Much of Ventura County sits in lower-risk coastal and urban areas. But parts of the county, including neighborhoods near open hillsides, canyons, and wildland-urban interface zones, carry real wildfire exposure, something local homeowners have seen play out firsthand in past fire seasons. That means insurance availability and cost can vary significantly from one block to the next, not just from one city to another. Two homes a few miles apart, both perfectly sound, can land in very different places when it comes to coverage options.
If You’re Selling
Before you list, it’s worth finding out whether your current policy would transfer smoothly to a new owner or whether a buyer might be looking at a very different quote. A buyer who gets a surprise on insurance midway through escrow can stall or unravel a deal that otherwise looked solid. Checking with your own carrier early, or simply asking what a comparable policy runs today, means there’s no unpleasant surprise once you’re under contract.
If You’re Buying
Build an insurance check into your plan the same way you’d handle a loan pre-approval, early, not as an afterthought. A few things worth doing before you remove contingencies:
- Request a sample insurance quote on a property before you write an offer, not after.
- Ask whether the home has had prior insurance claims or a non-renewal.
- If a property is currently insured through the FAIR Plan, ask what a standard market policy would cost by comparison.
- Bring a licensed insurance agent into the conversation early, rather than during the final week of escrow.
On certain properties, particularly those near open hillsides, the insurance line item can move your total monthly payment more than people expect. Knowing that number before you’re emotionally attached to a property puts you in a much stronger position.
A Quick, Important Note
This isn’t legal, tax, or financial advice, and it isn’t insurance advice either. Coverage options, eligibility, and pricing are changing as the state’s reforms play out, and they vary by carrier and by property. For anything specific to your situation, confirm current options and numbers with a licensed insurance agent or broker, and loop in your lender and the local real estate board with any related questions.
The Bottom Line
Insurance has quietly become part of how a transaction gets planned, not just closed. For move-up buyers and sellers juggling a sale and a purchase in the same window, the earlier that piece gets handled, the fewer surprises there are later on. That’s the kind of thing a well-managed transaction accounts for from day one.
Doug Miller, RE/MAX Gold Coast, Remedios Team | (661) 607-7500
Leave a Reply